Film Theory: Yes, Mirabel DOES Have A Gift! (Encanto)

  Baxış 6,569,438

The Film Theorists

The Film Theorists

3 ay əvvəl

Don't miss a Film Theory! ► bit.ly/1dI8VBH
The question on everyone's mind after finishing Encanto seems to be one thing. Does Mirabel ACTUALLY have a Gift? You see, she seemed to be the only one able to save the family and hold them together. There is a lot of speculation that hidden somewhere in there is a secret power. Today we are going to figure out what that may be and what it means for the Madrigal family.
Get your Theory Wear! ► creatorink.co/u7o
Don't miss a Film Theory! ► bit.ly/1dI8VBH
Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get Your 30 Day Free Trial Now ► share.epidemicsound.com/TheFil...
MORE FILM THEORIES
Rick's True CRIME! | Rick and Morty ►► bit.ly/2MVhP2W
Will MORTY KILL RICK?! ►► bit.ly/2qKFFFV
How PICKLE RICK Functions! ►►► bit.ly/2JvU4fT
Blair Witch's SECRET DANGER! ► bit.ly/2qhmv7a
Ariel & Hercules Are RELATED?! ► bit.ly/32WnVWi
Credits:
Writers: Matthew Patrick and Bob Chipman
Editors: Danial "BanditRants" Keristoufi, Jerika (NekoOnigiri), and Dan "Cybert" Seibert
Assistant Editor: Caitie Turner (viridianrosette)
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman

Şərh: 16 155
Just Some Guy without a Mustache
Just Some Guy without a Mustache 3 ay əvvəl
As someone who's never even seen Encanto, watching this made me realize that there's a lot more to these animated movies than meets the eye.
Isabella and creepy house
Isabella and creepy house 12 gün əvvəl
Yeqh
Clare McCulloch
Clare McCulloch 15 gün əvvəl
Why do I see you in comments so much?
Jenn&Josh House
Jenn&Josh House 18 gün əvvəl
What about pepa cloud
Tranum Kamra
Tranum Kamra 23 gün əvvəl
@otore 169th like
Natanja Breet
Natanja Breet 27 gün əvvəl
So true!!
just an average rock
just an average rock Ay əvvəl
Question: If Mirabel’s Mom has the ability to heal people with food, why can’t she help Mirabel see good without glasses?
iM fAm0uSe
iM fAm0uSe 2 gün əvvəl
@Col. Radec ooooh thats true
just an average rock
just an average rock 28 gün əvvəl
@Melissa I think they just did it for character design tbh
Dekenya Townsend
Dekenya Townsend 28 gün əvvəl
thats not how that works-
Amisha
Amisha Ay əvvəl
Tbh Mirabel looks so good with her glasses without her glasses she would not like very nice
Col. Radec
Col. Radec Ay əvvəl
The glasses represent having a different perspective on things
Kay W
Kay W Ay əvvəl
Interesting. When I saw the movie, I knew before the end of it what Mirabel's power was, not because of all the details you pointed out, but because of one you seemed to have missed. The thing I noticed was that the house was responding to Mirabel's own state. When she was happy and fine, so was the Casita, but the moment she began feeling doubt, insecurity, hurt... like she didn't belong, the cracks started to show... it was like the house was mirroring her and so of course the cracks were gone when everyone rushes back because Mirabel wasn't dwelling on her own problems anymore. She was so overwhelmed with concern for the home and what it meant for the family that when everyone was there, everything was fine again. The fact that the cracks Bruno was fixing were under the surface, mirrors the fact that Mirabel has spent her entire life HIDING the hurt and struggle she's had with not having a gift that is like the rest of her family. So of course, by the time the climax comes with the big fight between Abuela and Mirabel, the house then falls apart... because she's broken and has finally exposed that brokenness to her family with such force that it snuffs out the candle and the house gives one last ditch effort to protect her even as it crumbles down around her. She never had a door because she had the entire home as her "door" the entire time and just didn't realize it as she was so wrapped up in what did happen that she and everyone else didn't realize what was actually going on. That, as you said, the role of keeper of the magic, was being passed down. Anyway, that's my 2 cents on this. Can't wait to see some more vids from you! I think it's cool you manage to juggle life as a parent along with all the vids you do. Especially since not all of them are child friendly (Lookin' at you Cooking Companions).
xolin
xolin 29 gün əvvəl
your text is even longer than the other guy
xolin
xolin 29 gün əvvəl
oh wait
Bobby Cox
Bobby Cox Ay əvvəl
When I first watched the movie I thought Dolores lied about Mirabel not having a gift because in “waiting on a miracle” the whole song everything has frozen BUT Mirabel and I thought her gift was freezing time
Kat J
Kat J Ay əvvəl
It’s that stamps she does during the song, reminds me of Elsa’s stamp in the let it go song. I’m not sure though I’m still swaying more to her being the next candle holder.
Tiggr1964
Tiggr1964 2 ay əvvəl
Although I mostly agree with this theory, I believe that Pedro’s spirit is in the candle. The reason it did not return with the house is because the family are no longer under any pressure, so Pedro has no reason to return and protect his family and is reincarnated into a butterfly to live out the rest of his life. I hope that made sense.
sunnysolaris23 Bakerstreet
sunnysolaris23 Bakerstreet 14 gün əvvəl
It could also be that abuela needed the memory of Pedro to keep the magic alive, and the candle was the symbol of their love and his sacrifice. As long as she had the candle, Pedro was still with her. So for her the candle and casitas magic were inseparable linked. But Mirabel never even met Pedro. She got her strenght from her loving family surrounding her. So she doesn't need the candle anymore. And neither did Abuela, because she tells Mirabel in the end that she understands now. When she asked Pedro for help, he sent Mirabel. It's like she can finally let go of her past and her grief (the candle) and embrace the future (Mirabel).
Jenn&Josh House
Jenn&Josh House 18 gün əvvəl
Camilo?
Stephanie Mendiola
Stephanie Mendiola 2 ay əvvəl
As a Spanish speaker, I can confirm that the word “casito” doesn’t exist when referring to a house. Casa is a feminine word, so the nickname “casita” is the only option you have to show that the house is either small and cute, or just to show love and affection towards it. So if the house really was the reincarnation of Pedro, the house would still be called “casita”. Just wanted to point that out.
iM fAm0uSe
iM fAm0uSe 2 gün əvvəl
@Luis Rivera same thing as pepa who calls antonio papito and tonito and abuela alma who also calls him tonito
Julio Martinez
Julio Martinez 23 gün əvvəl
@Doodle Samuraiin casual conversation saying something is small is on the premise of something being of an intimate possession , most people say " check out my Little collection" in a sense of irony or sarcasm like when your mom is mad at you and says "say goodbye to your lil friends" that's basically it lol
Sarah Aviles
Sarah Aviles Ay əvvəl
Thank you! Came to the comments to say this.
marco mejia
marco mejia Ay əvvəl
Caso exists like a case or a basket so you could add ito to make it a small casito
Angel Guandique
Angel Guandique Ay əvvəl
Yeah
Matick
Matick 2 ay əvvəl
If MatPat just saw the lyrics of “Dos Oruguitas” better, it legit says “dos oruguitas, enamoradas” or “two caterpillars, in love” so the 2 “oruguitas” are Alma and Pedro (also fun fact "Alma" means "Soul" in Spanish)
BendeyWendy
BendeyWendy Ay əvvəl
When Mirabel opens the door to casita at the end, it lights up like her family members' individual doors at their ceremonies, indicating that the whole house is her own space - her magic is the casita itself.
Dhruva Cheethirala
Dhruva Cheethirala 24 gün əvvəl
I think there's a small hole in the theory. Abuela has a door, even though she is a keeper of the candle. If the keeper gets to have a door, how come Mirabel didn't get one?
dotcom
dotcom 21 gün əvvəl
Her door is the door of casita at the end
mork calling orson
mork calling orson Ay əvvəl
For a split second I thought Mirabel gift was to stop time or see the future because she was the only one who saw the house crack this was the same scene I thought she had the gift to stop time as well with her solo. But her gift is clearly understanding a moving house. Which in a way might mean she can talk to the dead because isn't the house her grandfather? Her other Gift is simply being emotionally strong. I did have a thought that all the other gifts resembles a little bit of mirabel but that's probably not true. This is the only Disney movie maybe even any movie (at least that I know of) where the main character doesn't need to learn anything. It was the people around her that needed to learn that powers doesn't make who you are. I found this aspect of the film the most interesting.
Benny Lewis
Benny Lewis 3 ay əvvəl
Love the theory, as always! But one minor correction; casita is feminine because casa is feminine. "Casito" would be something completely different (little case), from "caso". In Spanish, you refer to the gender of the object, rather than implied human gender. For instance, "mi amor" or "el amor de mi vida" is masculine, but can be used just as easily to refer to a female. It would never be *la amor de mi vida, so it similarly would never be *el casita, even if the theory of the casita being the soul of the abuelo were true.
My Name
My Name 24 gün əvvəl
@Franco Pico De nada.
Franco Pico
Franco Pico 24 gün əvvəl
@My Name Well yes, that makes much sense, casi means almost or barely, that diminutive is used much more in Hispano -America. ¡Thanks!
My Name
My Name 25 gün əvvəl
@Estebatrón Caso means case, and casi means something that happened near you. For example: Casi me golpeó la cabeza. (Translated: It almost hit my head.) you don't say "case hit my head."
Estebatrón
Estebatrón 25 gün əvvəl
@My Name I think it's a diminutive of "caso" and that as a diminutive of "casi" it's only used colloquially
My Name
My Name 25 gün əvvəl
Wasn't casito like diminutive form of casi and not caso?????
AJCOOLX
AJCOOLX 2 ay əvvəl
They really need to make a part 2
Le Monarque
Le Monarque 2 ay əvvəl
Yeah, I just now realized that Mirabel is in the center of the new Casita's main door, with Alma to the side. Previously, Alma was in the center of everything. There are too many open subplots and hints in this movie. There has to be a sequel!
Snowy playz roblox
Snowy playz roblox Ay əvvəl
Did you know that in the song All of you at the end when they need a doorknob Antonio gives the doorknob and says she made it just for her and if you look closely at it is has the letter M for Mirabel or Miracle or Madrigal is this because Mirabel didn't get a door because she holds the family together and she gets her initial on the Casita door?
Mali Boyd
Mali Boyd Ay əvvəl
Mirabel is always shown sewing or creating art for each of the family members but there is a specific emphasis on sewing, with her gift to Antonio and the fact she sewed the butterflies onto her dress- this could be a cheeky metaphor to how she kinda “sewed” the family back together
DanishStina
DanishStina 3 ay əvvəl
Also: Did anyone notice how the gifts reflected Alma's needs? I think casita chose the gifts for the family member based on what Alma needs at the time. Her children got the gifts of weather manipulation, clairvoyance and healing, because at the time Alma had lost her husband and her home. So casita gave Pepa weather powers to help grow food for the community, Julietta got healing so that Alma would never lose someone again, and Bruno got the power of foresight to warn them of any dangers. In the next generation most gifts seems to be flashier than their mothers. Dolores helps Alma get information about the village just like she does in the movie. Camillo and Louisa's gifts are to remind the village how powerful and helpful they are. While Isabella perfect candidate for the Madrigals to gain more influence in the village just like mentioned in the movie. When Mirabel received her 'gift' as the next keeper, that was because that was the only thing missing at the time to sure the legacy of the Madrigals. When Mirabel didn't receive any powers, Alma was so desperate that all she needed was a gift for Antonio. Literally any gift would do, so casita gave him something within his interest, animals.
Miriam Town
Miriam Town 2 ay əvvəl
Took me a bit to read, but yeah!!
Fefi Edmond
Fefi Edmond 2 ay əvvəl
@Pajaro Chango Dolores powers are an extension of Bruno: she could hear if someone was plotting anything against the family or the community, she could probably if anything happens under the soil (preparing them for a natural disaster), only to list two things. On the other hand, Camillo could work on the emotional part of the community: the best duty I could think of it's for him to help others with the closure of the death of a beloved one, calm the babies using their mother's voice and lift morals by saying the words others need to hear using the voice from the person they are craving the words (this last one isn't that healthy, but I put it in because sometimes it's all that's needed). So, even if not that extended in their sphere of action, all gifts are helpful for the family, whether an extension for someone else's gift, whether to treat more specific of deep needs.
Squashboy12
Squashboy12 3 ay əvvəl
@Aquarius Amethyst But Can Camilo Commit Identity Theft Without Being Caught Answer No Reason : Dolores
Z
Z 3 ay əvvəl
@Pajaro Chango idk man i'd trust the actual moms more than you
Aiden Schmittauer
Aiden Schmittauer 3 ay əvvəl
You seem to know to much , awesome explanation 👏
Lucy Lang
Lucy Lang 2 ay əvvəl
Thanks, I like this explanation, I kind of wish they included more of it in the film. Maybe it means we’ll get a sequel where mirabel is the head of casita
5Puff
5Puff Ay əvvəl
I never realized the insane amount of detail in this movie, it just makes it even better
Dante
Dante Ay əvvəl
I know you’ve done a Bee Movie theory before but, hear me out, I think a theory estimating how many bees would actually be needed to hold and fly a plane would be very interesting to watch. (Or if it’s even possible for any amount of bees to do so)
Romeo Rich
Romeo Rich Ay əvvəl
For real though: Thank you Thank you so much for clearing up the butterfly symbolism that’s been fluttering around the movie…When I got done listening to “All of you” in the movie, I finally realized that even a butterfly was on the candle…the first time that a butterfly was shown, timeline speaking, was when Abuela and Abuelo notice each other. A butterfly fluttered in front of Abuelo and coincidentally met eyes with Abuela…But Abuela did see him first, still there had to have been some kind of outside force that brought them two together…I wanna ask: How is it that a single lonesome butterfly coincidentally flutters past Abuelo to only meet see Abuela at the right time and angle…Was the event that they were at and the community were celebrating has some kind of spiritual energy that caused? I am going deep deep dish than you, MattPatt…I just wanna get rid of this heavy weight that the movie gave me like you did when you first started the FNAF series and a couple of Sonic theories (They were a nightmare and a half for me hahaha)
Dovydas Daunoravičius
Dovydas Daunoravičius 3 ay əvvəl
Mirabel is to enherit the house. The ending is pretty clear when she puts the knob on the door the door reacts to her. She didn't get a door in the house because the door to the house is hers.
Oh ur Special
Oh ur Special 5 gün əvvəl
@Lena Foxy im with you guys on this one :v
Crysta Blade
Crysta Blade 14 gün əvvəl
@Lena Foxy she's only in front because she's the one who brought them all together. If the door was ment to be just HER power it would have shown her and just the candle like Abuela's door.
Lena Foxy
Lena Foxy 2 ay əvvəl
@Crysta Blade But notice how Mirabel is IN FRONT? Doors represent someone's gift. Its pretty clear that the door is hers and her gift is being the new leader of the family.
Cool clips and vids
Cool clips and vids 3 ay əvvəl
It's inherit, not enherit btw.
Snowy Forest
Snowy Forest 3 ay əvvəl
Inherit*
SortaSamm
SortaSamm Ay əvvəl
I really love this theory!! I think it’s probably my favorite so far. I really felt like the ending was lacking something but now that I understand it, it’s a lot more powerful. My theory is that if we get Encanto 2, it will be the passing of Alma and the tree handing off casita to Mirabel.
Michelle Parsons
Michelle Parsons Ay əvvəl
This is exactly what I thought after watching this movie. My little girl loves it! I've seen it idk how many times now and cant tell you how many times we've sung we dont talk about bruno lol but i thought mirabel was taking over abuelas job so to speak. So i agree!
maksys93
maksys93 3 gün əvvəl
After watching the movie i came up with literally the same theory .... I was mostly confused as to no one seemed to wonder why Mirabel ceremony "failed". The encanto is unique in the world and even if so far no one failed there wasn't enough ceremonies to make Alma expert at how it works. No one except in my opinion Bruno actually tried to understand why Mirabel didn't get a gift.And with his power he was to be the one alerting the family that "not everything was perfect". Bruno was exiled simply because he was telling truth that no one wanted to hear.
Aheront
Aheront 4 gün əvvəl
Something that supports this theory is the fact that when Mirabel's door disparaged, the candle trembled. Alma was hesitant to give Mirabel her gift because it meant to give her the candle, the "leadership" of the Madrigals. She was insecure to let the family in her hands, just as it happens when someone younger takes the place of an older person. Because Alma wasn't ready to let go and move on from her duty, she still wanted to be the strong pillar of the community.
V
V 3 ay əvvəl
Hey Matpat, real quick, “Casito” or “El casa” doesn’t exist. That’s why they call the house “Casita”, because “casa” (which means home or house or whatever) is a feminine noun
Saul Nava
Saul Nava 8 gün əvvəl
Exactamente.
V
V 10 gün əvvəl
@Hyrulistic There is no alternative which is why Matpat’s point doesn’t make sense. There is no masculine way of saying home/house in Spanish. Casa, Hogar, casita… all feminine
Hyrulistic
Hyrulistic 10 gün əvvəl
As an English only speaker, but with slight awareness of masculine/feminine nouns in Spanish... I felt the point MatPat made still makes sense, i.e. "if the family believed the house was the embodiment of the grandfather, why did they use the {standard} feminine noun?" Like... I don't know what the alternative would be either, like there probably isn't really a Spanish way to say "hello Mr. the House!" without it getting confusing? If my house identifies as male..... some languages may not have existing words for that? 🤷‍♂️
Ella-Rae Amedume
Ella-Rae Amedume 14 gün əvvəl
FINNALY SOMEONE THAT KNOWS PROPER SPANISH
OneWhoDreamsAwake
OneWhoDreamsAwake 14 gün əvvəl
Yeah, that bugged me too. I think that’s the issue with not really understanding a language and then using the grammatical context of a different language to make inferences. Like trying to rhyme in Japanese (FYI, you can’t). Lol He might have been trying to pull a “Casita is she like a ship” kind of thing.
I Bee Stien
I Bee Stien Ay əvvəl
this is why The theory channels will always be my mainstay on youtube. always giving me something to mull over and ponder with my favorite bits of media and entertainment. Giving me a reason to experience it again with a new understanding. From the core of my being Thank you Matt Patt.
ThePlushieCrew
ThePlushieCrew Ay əvvəl
Only the first time I watched Encanto, I theorized/figured out that what was breaking the magic was broken family bonds. When Mirabel is hugging Isabela or whatever, the magic thrives and the cracks disappear. Yet during Mirabel and Alma’s confrontation, the cracks destroy the house and the candle goes out. Really, I don’t know how I theorized that but that’s my first theory.
Goliathon's Cave
Goliathon's Cave Ay əvvəl
Nice breakdown. I would suggest, however, that the images on the doors may be dynamic and show the family member at their current age.
F
F 2 ay əvvəl
Wow this was eye opening. I adore the movie even more now. So relatable for many people.
Tyler Ray
Tyler Ray 3 ay əvvəl
Also touching the door knobs is what gives each person their room. At the end mirabel touches the front door handle. So it's her house. Symbolically the new leader. Phenomenal movie
dio
dio Ay əvvəl
@Aaron McCoy don't try to uncorrected it
dio
dio Ay əvvəl
@Lena Foxy and everyone has an opinion
dio
dio Ay əvvəl
@Aaron McCoy and answer this question then why did Mirabel open the door and the magic without the candle light and who's gonna take abuela places
dio
dio Ay əvvəl
@Aaron McCoy bruh why are you acting like your theory confirm by the creator
Lena Foxy
Lena Foxy 2 ay əvvəl
@Evan Stephens In the book she did get a room at the end. Its possible the movie just doesn't show it. Also, she clearly did get a door. I guess you forgot that whole end scene when she puts the knob on the door and everyone's on it and she's infront meaning her gift is holding the family together?
AshleyTheFighter
AshleyTheFighter 2 gün əvvəl
Oh my gosh, the designs on Mirabel's dress blew my mind If that isn't hard evidence that the animators knew what's up, I don't know what is
The FireBird
The FireBird Ay əvvəl
It's amazing that the ones chosen to protect and unite the "gifted" ones are giftless. Yet their role is more powerful. The gifted are direction,and in effect, useless without them!
JELS
JELS Ay əvvəl
Theory: I think that the candle had some “thing” it was “whoever had the candle when it went out they will have the magic of the casita and if they are sad at a point will become the magic of casita” I think that’s a theory
MadMax2k
MadMax2k Ay əvvəl
this movie is so beautiful, it has something for everyone. i cried so many times and i cry every time i watch it
Jan Fick
Jan Fick 3 ay əvvəl
In regards to Antonio's door depicting him as a child. I always thought that the door would 'grow up' with it's owner, and that everybody started with a child version of themselves on their doors
Nathan Gamble
Nathan Gamble Ay əvvəl
@Nattie Thanks for pointing this out. I was wondering why no-one else was talking about this in the comments or why Matpat didn't notice it.
Joshua Rybinski
Joshua Rybinski 2 ay əvvəl
I this this is right. It would be weird to see what you would look like as an adult when you’re like 8.
YEET
YEET 2 ay əvvəl
I heard a theory that the doors depicted them as the last form before the casita got destroyed
Balance of The hill
Balance of The hill 2 ay əvvəl
@root / ringy the house have him that power
The Bloontuber
The Bloontuber 3 ay əvvəl
@Jan Fick Matpat said that to be the version Abuela wants them to be: As perfect can be.
cream476
cream476 2 ay əvvəl
In an interview one of the creators of Encanto said that the candle is a symbol of Abuela's unconditional love for her family. It wavers when Mirabel doesn't get a gift because of how upset Abuela was in the moment causing her love to also waver. It only goes out entirely when Abuela realizes that she had, in fact, been putting conditions on her love for her family without realizing it for years. This is also evidence that the magic moved on to Mirabel because she DID love her family unconditionally even when they weren't on the best terms.
Ann Victor
Ann Victor 2 ay əvvəl
What's your theory about why Mirabel still needs glasses when her mom can heal with food?
Chara MCnuggers
Chara MCnuggers Ay əvvəl
Uhh... because needing glasses is not an illness??
Shame_Cakes /
Shame_Cakes / Ay əvvəl
5:30 Funny that the word “casito” is most certainly NOT a word in Spanish. The word ‘house’ can ONLY be referenced as casa or casita. I am not Colombian, but I know for a fact that no where in Latin American cultures do not they use the word ‘casito’. I should know because I’m Venezuelan. Listen if want to prove a point, state out the facts. Not all the words in Spanish are feminine and masculine. Like ‘agua’ you never say ‘aguo’ that isn’t a word (agua means water). There are some words with exceptions like ‘brasileño’ and ‘brasileña’ (Brazilian). There are other words that make a COMPLETELY different meaning like ‘media’ (sock) and ‘medio’ (middle). This was bothering me, so I had to get it out. Sorry, not sorry. *Edit, I just found out that casito can be referenced as a small case, but even then I pretty sure people would regularly say "un caso pequeño" (a small case). Besides those two words have different meanings, signifying that your "proof" that Pedro wasn't the casita reincarnated because the Madrigals 'picture' the casita as a feminine figure is thrown out the window*
Laura Markhus
Laura Markhus Ay əvvəl
You just gotta appreciate the memes at the end of each theory that MatPat puts there for us
MapleSunflower
MapleSunflower 3 ay əvvəl
Adding onto this: we learn in the movie that Casita can't be controlled inside of the magical rooms. Mirabel is connected to Casita, but if she had a magic room she wouldn't have spent as much time with Casita.
Mark P.
Mark P. 2 ay əvvəl
If Casita couldn't be active inside any of the bedrooms, Mirabel would certainly already know it.
melodramatic7904
melodramatic7904 2 ay əvvəl
@Midnight Creepypastas & Hörbucher he couldn't reach the candle because he lost his powers. They showed Isabel trying to reach the candle with her power, then they show her door goes out, and she falls. They then show the exact same sequence with Camilo.
Midnight Creepypastas & Hörbucher
Midnight Creepypastas & Hörbucher 2 ay əvvəl
@DrawNeoisi Camilo didn’t use his powers on purpose tho. He literally did _not_ reach the candle _because_ he transformed at the wrong time.
Sapphia
Sapphia 2 ay əvvəl
It more like how mirabel was practicing for becoming the next head. She is sympathetic, listens to others, looks into the situation and is encouraging. Like how others practice in there magical rooms, develop their powers and do not rely much on casita like abuela or mirabel does. So yeah.
DrawNeoisi
DrawNeoisi 3 ay əvvəl
I think the same. Not much because Casita cant be controlled inside of the magical rooms, but because every Madrigal relies so much on the magic they inherited. You can see it when Luisa lost her gift she literally couldn't and wouldn't do anything, and when they tried to rescue the candle, Isabella and Camilo used their power to try to catch it (Not knowing what to do when they lost their powers in the middle of that act). But Mirabel's only magic she can rely on is the magic of casita. I feel is her way to feel part of the Madrigal family.
Lindsay Katzer
Lindsay Katzer 5 gün əvvəl
I always figured that since the doors are magical, the picture of the person just changed to match it's inhabitant as they grow. It would be weird if it started out showing what they looked like 15 years in the future.
Sovi
Sovi 16 gün əvvəl
Like my friend once said "She controls time, we can literally see her stopping time when she starts to sing"
iM0rb1d
iM0rb1d 27 gün əvvəl
Its so strange. After watching this movie I was convinced that Mirabels gift was being the magic's stable spot at the end of the movie. Then I watch this and it makes even more sense to me.
JF_ kein_K
JF_ kein_K Gün əvvəl
Makes me wonder, would the story have been different if Mirabel was the oldest child instead? (Her and Isabel switched ages for example) Would she have been shunned more by Alma, would she have been seen in a guardian role for her younger siblings/cousins...
Mark Ritzman
Mark Ritzman 3 ay əvvəl
While it doesn’t show for all of the family, one thing I noticed is that Mirabel’s symbols on her clothes show appreciation for the beauty of her family’s gifts rather than a strict representation of what they are. Dolores’ clothes may have sound waves (noise), but Mirabel wears music. Julieta’s clothes are about herbs and healing, but Mirabel honors her with a warm meal.
kitchensinkchronicles
kitchensinkchronicles 3 ay əvvəl
great observation!
Lily Ung
Lily Ung 3 ay əvvəl
I just noticed Luisa and Isa symbol on Mirabel's skirt: Luisa's symbol has hearts representing love and adoration for luisa, and Isa symbol isn't just roses and all perfect, but it represent her cuz remember when Isa was expressing herself for the first time in her music video and it were blue flowers?
Savannah Vance
Savannah Vance 3 ay əvvəl
Noce
Hidden Scorpius
Hidden Scorpius 28 gün əvvəl
5:34 That's because "Casito" doesn't mean "little house", Matt. 6:22 Or, the image could "grow" with them. You don't get a good look at all the doors when the image appears to completely assert that it depicts the adult selves.
Sophie
Sophie 2 ay əvvəl
I really love this movie, the songs and everything.
Quirky Qid
Quirky Qid 2 ay əvvəl
MATPAT as an oc in Encanto would have a power like Delores, definitely having an over analysis gift that he wouldn't be able to turn off
Sarah Olivo
Sarah Olivo Ay əvvəl
From what I've honestly analyzed since Abuela founded the miracle, it makes sense that her name starts with an A (since it's Abuela Alma). Mirabel seems to be the representation of a physical and emotional bridge of the family (I may not know how to really say this), since the initial to her name would be MM (including her last name). So it's like AM (beginning, for Abuela since she founded the miracle), them MM (continuation for Mirabel to pass the miracle on).
insanelaughterchick2
insanelaughterchick2 3 ay əvvəl
Another detail I noticed was that Mirabel affected the gifts of her sisters: Luisa started losing her gift faster than everyone else did because Mirabel thought she was carrying too much after "Surface Pressure". But then during "What Else Can I Do?", when Mirabel is actively encouraging Isabela and hyping her up, Isabela's power grows so much that it extends all the way into town from Casita's rooftops. I really liked that detail!
Merp Queen
Merp Queen 3 ay əvvəl
@Derek Joyce they said "her older sister", "her" referring to Mirabel. They did not say "the oldest sister"
Derek Joyce
Derek Joyce 3 ay əvvəl
@menjivarTv actually, Luisa is the middle child. She may have noticed the soonest because her gift is always on and she was lifting something heavy at the time.
Anonymous
Anonymous 3 ay əvvəl
@menjivarTv I think Luisa was the first affected because she probably was the only one to actually consider that maybe Mirabel was telling the truth about the cracks because we know Isabella doesn’t have the utmost respect for her and everyone else doesn’t understand her like Luisa and may have thought she called them over out of spite or jealousy of Antonio receiving a gift after she didn’t. that’s just my take on it though
Koku Cat
Koku Cat 3 ay əvvəl
On that topic, Bruno's door also lights up when he uses his gift with Mirabel. The other family members' doors were always illuminated, but Bruno's was dark.
Dusty Silva
Dusty Silva 2 ay əvvəl
I've been saying that since I first watched it lol. My kids were like she doesn't get a power! I was like, well I mean, she technically IS the power she's probably taking over for Abuela. A new age a new leader. No one believed me lol. Good to know that I might be right.
honeypetal
honeypetal 2 ay əvvəl
This video gave my brain some closure, tying up all those theories and thoughts in my own head so we'll 😂 one thing I will say though, it's never explicitly shown in the film that the doors start off with adult versions of the children once they recieve their gift. It is different to see with Antonio once we do! But its a magical house! I always assumed it just changes as they grow up. Like I'm sure Mirabels mother has a room with a door, right? It would be strange if it still looked like her as a teen. And the doors reflect their clothing and hair perfectly as well. Ik it's an animation and all the characters where the same outfit everyday 😭 but definitely seems important still. Showing is visuals on the door in the first place feels like a look into the magic of it all! Just me?👀
0mgtransfat
0mgtransfat Ay əvvəl
FINALLY! I've seen so many people talking about this movie as if Mirabel "didn't get a gift in the end," which wasn't how I read it at all. She got the same kind of gift Abuela got.
Riff Silver
Riff Silver 27 gün əvvəl
You know I thought her gift when I watched was she controls the house the best, that being in the evidence of this theory makes me happy
Ynsomniac Typho
Ynsomniac Typho 3 ay əvvəl
Just to clarify, the song "Dos oruguitas" actually talks about Abuela and Pedro as the song states "Dos oruguitas enamoradas" which translates to "two caterpillars in love with each other". As a native spanish speaker I understood what this song was about the very first time I listened to it, since in the movie it plays along abuela's memories of Pedro.
questionmark576
questionmark576 Ay əvvəl
All the songs are about many things. That's why the movie is so compelling. Just look at the Bruno song. They're talking about Mariano, but they're actually talking about Bruno. They're talking about Bruno in the past, but they're really talking about Bruno in the present. The house is a cocoon they have to break out of and rebuild their lives together. There are many types of love.
Phoenix Staley
Phoenix Staley 3 ay əvvəl
@ZM Yeah, I listened to the English version too, and it is nice and holds the central theme of the original, but it isn't a word-for-word translation. Even if it was, some of the words in the original, like "enamoradas," don't have a direct translation
Phoenix Staley
Phoenix Staley 3 ay əvvəl
As a fellow Spanish speaker, I want to highlight this comment ^ English doesn't have a direct translation of the word "enamoradas," but this word could only describe Abuela Alma and Abuelo Pedro, or another couple in love with each other.
Ellie Orf
Ellie Orf 3 ay əvvəl
@bezeani88 yes, yes it was. For about a month I believe. It was put in theaters at the end of last November.
bezeani88
bezeani88 3 ay əvvəl
@Ellie Orf it was in theaters?
Lindsay Arrieta
Lindsay Arrieta Ay əvvəl
I would love to see the room one by one 🙃
Deadgaming12YT
Deadgaming12YT Ay əvvəl
As someone who has watched the movie and speaks the language I can honestly say that this is the closest explanation to this movie like I didn’t get some parts until MatPat explained it
Ng Xin Yu
Ng Xin Yu 17 gün əvvəl
My theory: If you can see, the doorknob of Mirabel’s door had “M” on it. When Antonio gave her a doorknob at the end it also had an “M” on it. So I’m guessing that when Mirabel touched the doorknob some problem happened and the magic didn’t go into the door and just went into the doorknob. They kept the doorknob for a very long time and finally took it out. It was the doorknob Antonio gave to Mirabel. Mirabel then puts the doorknob in to the house’s door and everyone got their gift back. As you know, the candle already went out and it can’t generate any magic anymore. The magic in the house now is Mirabel’s. Mirabel’s magic is controlling the whole house.
LSfox
LSfox 27 gün əvvəl
My interpretation of Antonio's door featuring him as a child and not an adult was that since casita is pretty much alive and can change, the image of the person on the door grows with them. So when Antonio got his door he was depicted on it as a child, overtime the image would change and depict an older him as he would get older and the reason why the doors immediately showed the adult versions of their respective characters was just to make it clearer in the flashback. Idk that's just how I look at it...
Heroes Rise Up
Heroes Rise Up 3 ay əvvəl
I bet the “This character IS this character” Theories always has MatPat sweating when he uploads them. Lol
EPC69
EPC69 3 ay əvvəl
@Don't read profile photo ok
RanOutOfIdeas
RanOutOfIdeas 3 ay əvvəl
Sans=Ness flashbacks
bunger plushie
bunger plushie 3 ay əvvəl
"sans is ness" "gregory is crying child" "the knight is the pale king"
saywhat?
saywhat? Ay əvvəl
hey man, after watching Encanto for the 30th time ( I have a 5 and 7 YOs, so I feel your pain) I hadn´t realized all these details... I still have 2 questions... why did the casita´s magic didn´t work in Bruno´s door and what about the pre'hispanic looking sculptures also inside his room... great content !!!!
Reidon Hoffnung
Reidon Hoffnung Ay əvvəl
I love the theory, but honestly, I stick to another explanation of the owners of the doors' depictions. I saw somewhere a theory that doors show family members of their age when the casita gets broken (and that's why Antonio is the only child-looking - because he is five when casita fell apart).
HigherKhaos
HigherKhaos 12 gün əvvəl
First time I watched this movie I literally said her gift was the same as Abuela's. I pointed it out that they both can "control" the house. But everyone was like "you're reading too much in to it"
KCWilliam
KCWilliam Ay əvvəl
Before I hear your theory: I'm gonna guess that the magic must be connected to a life force to stay with the family and the grandmother's life force has been waning. But since no one's explained that to the family everyone's fricking out!
Aidan Eaglesfield
Aidan Eaglesfield 3 ay əvvəl
Nobody's talking about how Mirabel's talented at stitching things back together? And how that is very obvious symbolism?
questionmark576
questionmark576 Ay əvvəl
@unnoticedones she even stitched together Antonio's gift.
jadedNoir98
jadedNoir98 2 ay əvvəl
Ooh! Good catch! I missed that detail.
Austin is thicc emo potato
Austin is thicc emo potato 2 ay əvvəl
And making stuff animals
Shelby Bayer
Shelby Bayer 2 ay əvvəl
That's a Talent NOT a power given by the house/candle If anything, she's giving herself the "Miracle" of talent to do those things She's literally the Miracle needed to bring the magic back The Candle may be gone but it's replaced with a new power source Mirabel herself her power is Miracles
Joe Jeanes
Joe Jeanes 2 ay əvvəl
@Mackenzie Woloschuk the real power was therapising so no wonder everyone avoided heen
Kennedy Wilson
Kennedy Wilson 4 gün əvvəl
I feel like Mirabel should’ve been the jack jack. Having different abilities.
Puzzlick
Puzzlick Ay əvvəl
Now I need a film theory on why Mirabels prediction from Bruno is the only one that wasn't set in stone and had two options.
InShru Tripathi
InShru Tripathi Ay əvvəl
Mirabel's gift was to be a home maker and a home wrecker at the same time. Quite literally.
Mr. Blueskies
Mr. Blueskies 6 gün əvvəl
0:25 Does anyone know if the texture inside the text was found from a image containing that type of texture? Or do you think it was re-created? Or do you think it was just somehow taken from the Encanto logo?
DeskHyena
DeskHyena 3 ay əvvəl
5:34 Hey Matpat. Little correction, "Casita" is the small version of the word "Casa" which means house, and is a femenine word so the family didnt name it "Casita" because its a femine house, but because the word is femine and "Casito" isnt an actual word, but still thanks :3 Edit: Sorry, I forgot the word for small case existed, my bad
Me Vitalized
Me Vitalized 3 ay əvvəl
@Monochrome Soul I feel like it still makes sense from a language standpoint. It's just awkward, cos, like you said, no one uses it that way.
Maria Ximena Otalora Cordoba
Maria Ximena Otalora Cordoba 3 ay əvvəl
@shadebug you know diminutives can be used for affection and endearment right? also, hogar doesn't mean the same as casa, is more like home, like the feeling of home, not the physical object, and for me a Finca encompases the rural area around a farmhouse, and in here we are talking just about the house, the physical constuction of the house, not the surounding area, but that is just the definition I have
Eyre Murasaki
Eyre Murasaki 3 ay əvvəl
Bueno, ¿Quién quiere Lacasitos? (Ya me voy, perdón por el chiste malo)
Ed Araujo
Ed Araujo 3 ay əvvəl
@Patoti claro! É nóis querido!
Bliss
Bliss Ay əvvəl
love your theorys especially this one :)
Shinylunar
Shinylunar Ay əvvəl
Mirabel’s real gift is either her being able to slow down time or moving so quick everyone is slo mo
TessLove
TessLove 2 ay əvvəl
3:51 My theory is that Mirabel didn't get a gift since she was the only one to wipe off her hands AFTER she touched the candle. The magic is inside her. And the magic got set free when Mirabel revived the house.
Scha Al-Edrus
Scha Al-Edrus Ay əvvəl
i love encanto! they're story is just wonderful
Avery McDonald
Avery McDonald 2 ay əvvəl
One key detail: she’s connected to the house, and the cracks only start become apparent to her when she’s really stressed out (Antonio’s ceremony, Isabela’s proposal, and her fight with Abuela), so there is a connection to casita right there. The cracks also only start appearing when Mirabel “doesn’t get a gift” and Bruno leaves, because Bruno repairs those cracks that appear because Mirabel is one with Casita. She also literally brings casita back to life, soooooooo yeah. That would also explain why she doesn’t hat a door, as instead, she has all of casita.
OJ
OJ 27 gün əvvəl
I think so too, she didn't get a room cuz her gift is literally the house (the ending supports that)
WingsOfFireFan6384
WingsOfFireFan6384 29 gün əvvəl
I heard why she didnt get a room is cause she'll get abeula room when she dies cause she's the candle holder
JesseDjayden Rouwenhorst
JesseDjayden Rouwenhorst Ay əvvəl
Thats what i thought
MatthewTheThinker
MatthewTheThinker Ay əvvəl
When the cracks first showed to the audience, it was during the party for Antonio. When Mirabel tried to show the family the cracks, they were all gone. Later on that night, Mirabel snuck over to the candle and heard Abuela talking about the magic fading and cracks in the house. That would mean that Abuela has seen OTHER cracks in the house outside of the ones caused during the movie. No?
Alexandria Gorham
Alexandria Gorham Ay əvvəl
Oooh okay I was wondering about when the mountain split and how that was connected but if the song outright says break down your walls and times are changing I guess that would explain and I cried when she went back to the river because the brief silence I knew abuela hadn’t been there since her husband had died
Dragonfly
Dragonfly Ay əvvəl
The only film theory that made me happier to have known it than not.
Thomas Wong
Thomas Wong Ay əvvəl
I think that Mirabeau gift is love because she did return the magic right and plus she was looking out for the family and she’s actually telling the truth.
NightSky_098
NightSky_098 Ay əvvəl
I've been wondering why Mirabel is named Mirabel it's like she's connected with the Miracle itself.
Velet - Aşk Sadece Anlayana
2:04
VELET MUSIC
Baxış 2,9M
Yasak Elma 142. Bölüm
1:50:17
Yasak Elma
Baxış 371K
Film Theory: What REALLY Saved Snow White!
14:08
The Film Theorists
Baxış 14M
Film Theory: The Lorax Movie LIED To You!
17:32
The Film Theorists
Baxış 8M
Annenin Sırrıdır Çocuk 6. Bölüm
1:51:08
Annenin Sırrıdır Çocuk
Baxış 1,5M
Kardeşlerim 52. Bölüm @atv
2:33:59
KARDEŞLERİM
Baxış 6M
Yücel ve Mustafa Dram Şov
13:36
Mami Emen
Baxış 1,1M
Seversin 1. Bölüm Fragmanı
1:07